The store says I needed the extended warranty. Is that right?

Why a faulty product is covered without an extended warranty, what to send the store and where to go when it still points to the plan.

Last updated
November 17, 2026
Cian CondonBy
Cian Condon
5 min read

AI-assisted research and reviewed for accuracy. Something out of date? Let us know.

Short answer

No. Under the Australian Consumer Law, a faulty product is covered by automatic consumer guarantees whether or not you bought an extended warranty, and the ACCC says stores must not mislead you into paying for those rights. The guarantee usually continues after the manufacturer's warranty ends. If the store still refuses, your state consumer agency or tribunal decides, and NSW Fair Trading can direct a remedy for products costing $25 to $3,000.

Already tried and got nowhere?
That's where we start. Our team takes it from here.

Hand it to Ajust

Do you need an extended warranty to get a faulty product fixed?

No. The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) gives every purchase automatic rights called consumer guarantees, such as the guarantee that a product is of acceptable quality, which includes being durable and free from defects (section 54). Those rights come with the product whether or not you bought an extended warranty.

The ACCC says extended warranties are optional, and businesses must not mislead consumers "into paying for rights in an extended warranty that they already have". In plain terms, a fault the consumer guarantees cover is the store's to fix, plan or no plan.

The law backs this up. Section 29(1)(m) of the ACL bans false or misleading statements about "the existence, exclusion or effect of any condition, warranty, guarantee, right or remedy". Section 64 makes any contract term that tries to exclude the consumer guarantees void.

The consumer guarantees usually outlast the manufacturer's warranty. The ACCC says that after a warranty against defects expires, the guarantee of acceptable quality "usually still applies", so you likely still have a right to a repair, replacement or refund.

The big retailers' own documents agree. Harvey Norman's Product Care page says "You are not required to pay for Your rights and remedies under the Australian Consumer Law." JB Hi-Fi says its warranty policies "are in addition to, and do not limit" your consumer guarantee rights. The Good Guys says its staff must make sure your ACL rights "are NOT limited in any way".

What you're claiming onConsumer guaranteesExtended warranty
Do you pay for it?No, it comes with the productYes, it's usually sold separately for an extra cost
Who you claim fromThe store that sold it to youWhoever provides the plan, which may be a different business from the store or manufacturer
How long it lastsA reasonable time, depending on the productThe period set out in its terms
What you can getMajor failure: your choice of refund or replacement. Minor failure: a repair within a reasonable time, or the store's choice of replacement or refundWhat its terms promise. The NSW Government suggests checking for exclusions, excess fees and claim limits
Can it be taken away?No. A term that tries to exclude the guarantees is voidIt runs on its own terms and conditions

A major failure is one where a reasonable person wouldn't have bought the product knowing about the problem, or it can't do its normal job and can't easily be fixed within a reasonable time. The page on when a store will only offer a repair explains the difference.

Getting this wrong has cost businesses before. In 2015 the Federal Court ordered Fisher & Paykel and Domestic & General to pay $200,000 each over letters that told appliance owners they wouldn't be protected against repair costs once the manufacturer's warranty ended unless they bought an extended warranty, the ACCC reported.

What should you do first?

If you've only been told this at the counter or on the phone, put your claim in writing before anything else. A written request is what a manager, an agency or a tribunal will ask to see.

Step 1: Keep your evidence

Keep your receipt or bank statement and photos or a short video of the fault. Note what staff said and when, such as "that's only covered under the extended warranty". If you bought a plan and a claim on it was refused, keep the plan's terms and the refusal.

Step 2: Ask the store in writing

Make the claim to the store, under the consumer guarantees, so its answer is about your legal rights rather than the plan's terms. Ajust's recommended channels:

  • Harvey Norman: the Compliments & Complaints form, naming the franchise store you bought from. The CustomerFirst email only sent an auto-reply in Ajust's cases.
  • JB Hi-Fi: a support request at support.jbhifi.com.au, or the store you bought from for in-store purchases.
  • The Good Guys: the contact form at thegoodguys.com.au/contact-us or customercare@thegoodguys.com.au. For faulty products, emailing the store you bought from often got a faster answer in Ajust's cases.
  • Any other store: whichever channel gives you a written record and a reference number, usually the web form.
Subject: Faulty [product]: request for a remedy

Hello,

On [date] I bought a [brand and model] from your [store or website] for $[price]. Since [date], it has [describe the fault]. Photos and my receipt are attached.

On [date] I was told the fault is only covered if I had bought an extended warranty. My claim is with you as the seller, and it doesn't depend on a warranty plan. I am asking for a [refund / replacement / free repair].

Please confirm in writing within 14 days how and when you will provide it.

Regards,
[Your name]

Step 3: Hold the store to a date

If the date passes or the answer is still "buy the plan", ask for the store manager. JB Hi-Fi and The Good Guys both say their store managers can approve a different remedy, and that you can then write to their ACL Warranty Claims Officer.

Already done all this and still being told you needed the extended warranty? Here's what happens next.

What if the store still says no?

Take it above the store, then outside it. Each route can help, but each has limits worth knowing before you start.

WhereWhat it doesWhere it stops
Store manager, then the retailer's ACL Warranty Claims Officer or head officeCan approve a remedy the counter refusedIt's still the store deciding about its own refusal
State consumer agency (NSW Fair Trading, Consumer Affairs Victoria, Queensland Office of Fair Trading)Contacts the store to try to reach an agreementIt can't force a result. Consumer Affairs Victoria says it "cannot enforce an outcome", and Queensland's Office of Fair Trading says it cannot force a business to compensate you or fix a problem. The NSW direction below is the exception
NSW Fair Trading consumer guarantee directionCan direct the store to repair, replace or refund. The store must comply within 28 daysOnly after Fair Trading's complaint process fails, and you have 30 days to ask. Products costing $25 to $3,000 (excluding GST), bought in the 6 months before you complained, with you and the business in NSW
Tribunal (NCAT, VCAT, QCAT)Hears the claim and makes an order the store must followYou prepare and present the case yourself, and application fees apply. In an NCAT consumer claim you need the tribunal's permission for anyone to represent you. NCAT: 3 years to apply, claims up to $100,000. QCAT: up to $25,000

Legal Aid NSW can fund a tribunal case about goods you bought, but only if you pass a means test and a merit test, and usually only once the store's complaints process and an outside one have been tried.

Can someone take this on for you?

Yes, when the claim is against the store that sold you the product.

Our team takes over your claim with the store and puts it on the consumer guarantees, not the plan's terms. We go past the counter to the store manager and the retailer's warranty claims team, hold the store to a date and lodge with Fair Trading or Consumer Affairs for you in NSW, Victoria, Queensland, SA and WA if it still refuses.

No win, no fee. We'll tell you straight if we don't think we can win it.

What we see in Ajust cases

Ajust has handled over 10 cases about extended warranties.

  • In these cases, the typical amount at stake is about $1,430.

Under the Australian Consumer Law, a major failure lets you choose a refund or replacement, while a minor one lets the business choose to repair, replace or refund.

What doesn't work

  • Buying extra cover to get this fault fixed. The consumer guarantees already apply to the fault you have now.
  • Treating a refused plan claim as the end. A plan's refusal is a decision under its own terms. Your claim against the store under the consumer guarantees is separate.
  • Accepting "it's out of warranty". The guarantee of acceptable quality usually continues after the manufacturer's warranty ends.
  • Relying on what the salesperson said about a plan. The NSW Government says the plan's written terms are what bind, so check them, not the sales pitch.
  • Arguing only at the counter. Without a written request there is nothing to show a manager, an agency or a tribunal.

Common questions

My extended warranty claim was refused. Do I still have rights?

Yes. A refusal under the plan is a decision about the plan's terms. Your consumer guarantee rights against the store are separate, and the NSW Government says an extended warranty does not replace them. You may still be entitled to a repair, refund or replacement even when a manufacturer's or extended warranty has ended.

Should I claim on the extended warranty or under consumer law?

You can use either. The ACCC says an extended warranty may or may not give you rights beyond the consumer guarantees, so compare its terms with what the law already gives you. If you do claim on the plan, tell the store in writing that your consumer guarantee claim against it still stands.

Can the store charge me for a repair once the manufacturer's warranty ends?

Not for a fault that breaks a consumer guarantee. The ACCC says the guarantee of acceptable quality usually still applies after a warranty against defects expires, so you likely still have a right to a repair, replacement or refund. How long the guarantee lasts depends on the product.

Is there a class action about extended warranties?

Two are running in the Supreme Court of Victoria. One is against JB Hi-Fi, for extended warranties bought from 1 January 2011 to 8 December 2023. Its trial began on 5 October 2026, and JB Hi-Fi denies the claims. The other is against Harvey Norman, Domayne and Joyce Mayne over Product Care bought from 18 September 2018 to 19 September 2024.

Fair Trading says it can't make the store fix it. What now?

Most state consumer agencies can only negotiate. Consumer Affairs Victoria says only a court or tribunal can enforce an outcome. In NSW you can ask Fair Trading for a consumer guarantee direction within 30 days, if the product cost $25 to $3,000. Otherwise the next step is your state's tribunal.

Ajust

Still owed? We'll take it from here.

Tell us what happened. Our team reviews your case and tells you straight if we can win it. No win, no fee.
Hand it to Ajust