My new car keeps breaking down. Can I get a refund or replacement?
When a fault keeps coming back after the dealer's repairs: what makes it a major failure, who owes you what and where to go when they say repair only.
AI-assisted research and reviewed for accuracy. Something out of date? Let us know.
Often, yes. Under the Australian Consumer Law, a major failure lets you choose a refund or a replacement instead of another repair, and since December 2020 several minor failures can together count as a major failure. A fault that can't be fixed within a reasonable time can count too. If the dealer still refuses, NCAT, VCAT or QCAT can order a refund, replacement or repair.
Already tried and got nowhere?
That's where we start. Our team takes it from here.
Can you get a refund for a new car that keeps breaking down?
You can, when the faults add up to a major failure. The Australian Consumer Law (ACL) gives every car bought from a dealer a guarantee that it is of acceptable quality, which includes being free from defects, safe and durable (section 54).
Under section 260, a failure is major when a reasonable buyer who knew about it wouldn't have bought the car, when the car is unsafe or when it can't be fixed without difficulty within a reasonable time. In plain terms, a car that keeps going back for the same fault is the situation that test was written for.
Since December 2020, 2 or more minor failures can together count as a major failure. Section 260(2) says they're taken as a whole, and they don't need to be the same fault. The ACCC says this change came in that month.
| Where you are | What the ACL gives you | Who chooses |
|---|---|---|
| One fault that can be fixed | A free repair within a reasonable time | The dealer chooses how to fix it |
| The dealer refuses, or doesn't fix it within a reasonable time | Have it fixed elsewhere and claim the reasonable cost back, or reject the car | You |
| A major failure, including several faults that together count as one | Reject the car for a refund or replacement, or keep it and claim the drop in value | You |
| A problem caused by misuse, or one you were told about before buying | No repair, replacement or refund, according to the ACCC | No one |
In February 2024 the Federal Court ordered Mazda Australia to pay $11.5 million in penalties. The ACCC says Mazda told 9 owners that repair was their only remedy, after multiple failed repairs including complete engine replacements.
The manufacturer's warranty doesn't replace any of this. The ACCC says voluntary warranties can't change or take away the automatic rights, and the dealer must not send you to the manufacturer for a remedy. Under section 271, you can also claim damages from the manufacturer itself when the car isn't of acceptable quality.
Queensland called its 2018 changes "lemon laws". They raised QCAT's limit for cars with a major fault or multiple minor faults to $100,000 (it was $25,000), and the remedies still come from the ACL.
What should you do first?
If every repair so far was booked through the service desk, put the whole history in writing to the dealer before anything else. A written claim for a refund or replacement is what the next step works from.
Step 1: Build the repair history
Collect the contract, every job card and invoice, the dates the car was off the road and any loan car records. Note the odometer reading at each fault, and keep photos or videos of warning lights.
Step 2: Ask for a refund or replacement in writing
Email the dealer principal, not the service desk, and copy the manufacturer's customer relations team. Ajust's recommended channel is whichever one gives you a written record and a reference number, usually email.
Subject: Refund or replacement for [year, make and model], VIN [number]
Hello,
I bought this car new from you on [date] for $[price]. It has been back [number] times for [describe the fault or faults], on [dates]. The fault has returned.
I don't accept another repair. I am asking for a [refund / replacement vehicle].
Please confirm in writing within 14 days how and when you will do this.
Regards,
[Your name]
Step 3: Hold them to the date
Keep driving only as the car safely allows, and note any new fault in writing as it happens. If the 14 days pass with no answer, or the answer is another repair, write back and say so.
Already done all this and still being told repair is the only option? Here's what happens next.
What if the dealer still only offers repairs?
Go above the dealer, then to a body that can order a result. Each route has a limit worth knowing before you start.
| Where | What it does | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|
| Dealer principal | Can approve a refund or replacement the service desk said no to | It's still the dealer deciding about its own sale |
| The manufacturer's customer relations team | Can offer a remedy the dealer won't. Under section 271 you can also claim damages from it | It didn't sell you the car, and the ACCC says the dealer must not send you to it for a remedy |
| NSW Fair Trading (or your state's consumer agency) | Free dispute resolution with licensed dealers and repairers. Complaints are usually assessed within 30 days | It's voluntary. NSW Fair Trading says its officer cannot order anyone to pay money or return a vehicle |
| NCAT (NSW) | Hears claims against a dealer and can order payment, a repair or a replacement. For a new car, it can order an unlimited sum | Apply within 3 years of the problem starting. Application fees apply, and you present the case yourself |
| VCAT (Victoria) | Hears goods and services claims, including cars | Expect to wait about 52 weeks for a hearing. Generally apply within 6 years. Application fees apply |
| QCAT (Queensland) | Hears consumer guarantee claims about new cars bought from a dealer or trader | Claims up to $100,000. A motor vehicle assessor's report of up to $1,200 may be split between you and the dealer |
NCAT says most people represent themselves, and VCAT generally doesn't allow a lawyer to speak for you on a goods claim under $15,000. Legal Aid NSW can fund a tribunal case about goods you bought if you pass its means and merit tests, usually once the dealer's complaints process and an outside one have been tried.
Can someone take this on for you?
Yes, when the dealer or manufacturer accepts the car has a fault, or its repair records show one, but will only keep repairing it. If the dealer disputes what caused the fault, that needs an expert to decide, and Ajust can't take it on.
Our team takes over your claim with the dealer. We go past the service desk to the dealer principal, then to the manufacturer's customer relations team, and hold them to a date. In NSW, Victoria, Queensland, SA and WA we can also lodge it with Fair Trading or Consumer Affairs for you.
No win, no fee. We'll tell you straight if we don't think we can win it.
What doesn't work
- Accepting "one more repair" with nothing in writing. A repair with no job card leaves no record of the date, the fault or the odometer reading.
- Taking the warranty booklet as the limit of your rights. The ACCC says a manufacturer's warranty can't change or take away the consumer guarantees.
- Going only to the manufacturer. The dealer sold you the car and owes the remedy. The ACCC says the dealer must not send you to the manufacturer for one.
- Waiting years to claim. NCAT's time limit for a car claim is 3 years from when the problem began.
- Selling the car to get out of it. A refund needs the car to go back to the dealer, and selling it ends that option.
Common questions
Is there a lemon law in Australia?
The rules that cover a lemon are the consumer guarantees in the Australian Consumer Law. Since December 2020 they say several minor faults can together count as a major failure, which gives you the choice of a refund or replacement. Queensland's 2018 "lemon laws" raised QCAT's limit for these car claims to $100,000.
How many repairs before it counts as a major failure?
The law doesn't set a number. The test in section 260 is whether a reasonable buyer who knew about all the faults, taken together, would have bought the car, or whether it can be fixed within a reasonable time. In the Mazda case, owners had been through multiple failed repairs, and one car had three engines.
The manufacturer says the fault is within spec. What now?
Ask for that in writing, with the specification it relies on. Under the ACL, acceptable quality is judged by what a reasonable buyer who knew the car's condition would accept. If you and the dealer disagree about what is causing the fault, QCAT can engage a motor vehicle assessor to report on the car.
Fair Trading says it can't make the dealer do anything. What now?
That's right for NSW Fair Trading: its officers can't order a dealer to pay money or take a car back. The step that can is the tribunal. In NSW you apply to NCAT within 3 years of the problem starting. In Victoria it's VCAT and in Queensland it's QCAT.
Does servicing at an independent mechanic affect my rights?
The ACCC says you can choose an independent repairer to service and repair your car, and car makers must make service and repair information available to them. The consumer guarantees still don't cover a problem caused by misuse, so keep the service records.
- Competition and Consumer Act 2010, Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law), sections 54, 259, 260, 262 and 271
- ACCC: New and second-hand cars
- ACCC: Mazda to pay $11.5m for misleading consumers about consumer guarantee rights
- NSW Government: Vehicle warranty and repair disputes
- NCAT: Motor vehicles
- VCAT: Before you apply, goods and services disputes
- QCAT: Motor vehicle disputes
- Queensland Government: When life gives you lemons, make lemon laws (15 November 2018)
- Legal Aid NSW: Consumer protection policy

Still owed? We'll take it from here.
Other
Retail
Issues
Read about the issues consumers are facing. Have a different issue? You can still make a complaint.
