Can the agent take my bond for fair wear and tear?
What counts as fair wear and tear, whether the age of carpet or paint matters, the evidence that helps and where to go if the agent won't drop it.
AI-assisted research and reviewed for accuracy. Something out of date? Let us know.
No. NSW, Victorian and Queensland rules all say a renter isn't responsible for fair wear and tear, so it can't be claimed from the bond. In Queensland you have 14 days from a Notice of claim to dispute it. If you and the agent can't agree, a state dispute service, commissioner or tribunal decides how the bond is paid.
Already tried and got nowhere?
That's where we start. Our team takes it from here.
Can an agent claim your bond for fair wear and tear?
No. Fair wear and tear is the normal ageing of a home that people live in, and it is kept out of a bond claim. A landlord or agent can still claim for damage, cleaning or unpaid rent.
NSW Fair Trading says a tenant "is not responsible for 'fair wear and tear'". Consumer Affairs Victoria says rental providers "can't claim bond to cover fair wear and tear". Queensland's Residential Tenancies Authority (RTA) describes it as changes from normal use and from "ageing and deterioration over time".
The hard part is where wear ends and damage starts. This is how the NSW Government and the RTA draw the line.
| Item | Fair wear and tear | Damage |
|---|---|---|
| Carpet | Furniture indentations and traffic marks. Pile worn or flattened by everyday use | Stains or burns. Stains from an approved pet (RTA) |
| Paint | Faded, chipped or cracked paint. Paint worn off near a light switch | Paint pulled off by posters stuck with blu-tack or tape. Discolouring from candle smoke (RTA). An unapproved, poor quality paint job |
| Curtains | Faded curtains or frayed cords | Missing or torn curtains |
| Floors and benchtops | Scuffed wooden floors. A worn benchtop | Badly scratched or gouged floors. Burns or cuts in a benchtop |
| Plaster | Cracks as the building settles (RTA) | Chips from hammering in nails (RTA) |
| Water stains on carpet | From a leaking roof or bad plumbing | From an overflowing bath or indoor pot plants |
The RTA adds that dirt, grime, grease and damage, including damage by an approved pet, are not fair wear and tear.
The age of the item can count too. Consumer Protection WA says the Commissioner "considers fair wear and tear and depreciation when deciding a claim", and asks landlords for the age of the item, such as when the walls were last painted or the floors were laid. In its example, a landlord who replaces a 5-year-old fridge may not be able to claim the full cost of a new one, because that would leave them better off than before. The NSW, Victorian and Queensland pages above don't mention age or depreciation.
The entry condition report is the main evidence. NSW Fair Trading calls it "evidence of how a rental property was before a tenant moved in". In Victoria an agent's evidence for a bond claim must not contradict the condition report.
A bond claim also starts a short clock. In Queensland you have 14 days to send the RTA a Dispute resolution request (Form 16), or the bond is paid as the first request directed. In NSW you apply to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) and notify NSW Rental Bonds before the "due for payment" date. The bond claim guide has the step for each state.
What should you do first?
Write down your deadline. If you've only argued about it at the final inspection or on the phone, put your objection in writing now.
Step 1: Match each item to the entry condition report
Keep your lease, both condition reports, dated photos from moving in and out, your bond number and every message about the claim. For each item claimed, note what the entry report says about it and how long you lived there.
Step 2: Write to the agent, item by item
Ajust's recommended channel is whichever one gives you a written record and a reference number, which for an agency is usually email to your property manager.
Subject: Bond claim for [property address]
Hello,
You have claimed $[amount] from my bond for [carpet / paint / curtains]. I lived at the property from [date] to [date].
I believe these items are fair wear and tear, not damage. [For example: the hallway carpet is marked as worn in the entry condition report.] My photos are attached.
Please remove these items from the claim, or send me the quotes and the age of each item, and reply in writing within 7 days.
Regards,
[Your name]
Step 3: Take it to the principal, then your state's dispute step
If the property manager won't remove the items, write to the agency's principal, the licensee in charge. Lodge your state's dispute step before the deadline, even if the agency says it is still looking at it.
Already done all this and still being told worn carpet is damage? Here's what happens next.
What if the agent still says it's damage?
Someone outside the agency can look at the claim, but each route has a limit.
| Where | What it does | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|
| The agent or landlord | Can take items off the claim | The side asking for the money is judging its own claim |
| The agency's principal | Can overrule the property manager | The agency is still deciding about its own claim |
| Free tenant advice service (Tenants Advice and Advocacy Services in NSW on 1800 251 101, Tenants Victoria, Tenants Queensland and the services in other states) | Advice on your side of the claim. The NSW Government says the NSW services give "assistance and advocacy" | They support you. They can't decide whether an item is wear or damage |
| State dispute service (RTA conciliation in Queensland, Rental Dispute Resolution Victoria (RDRV), the Commissioner for Consumer Protection in WA) | The RTA and RDRV help both sides try to agree. In WA the Commissioner decides how the bond is paid and weighs depreciation | The RTA says its conciliators "do not determine who is 'right' or 'wrong'", and taking part is voluntary. NSW Fair Trading's tenancy complaint service doesn't handle bond claims. A WA decision can be appealed to the Magistrates Court within 7 days |
| Tribunal (NCAT, VCAT, QCAT and the tribunals in other states) | Hears both sides and orders how the bond is paid | You bring and explain your own evidence. NCAT charges $64 for a residential tenancy application, with a reduced fee for some people. RDRV says a hearing may incur a fee |
At NCAT the automatic right to a representative covers only a few case types, and tenancy isn't one of them, so a lawyer can speak for you only with NCAT's permission. You don't need permission to get legal advice while you prepare.
Can someone take this on for you?
Yes, if you rent from a private landlord or agent.
Our team writes to the agent or landlord with the facts from your lease and condition reports, asks for a reply within 7 days, and takes it to the agency's principal if they still refuse. If it isn't resolved, we prepare your answers for your state's free dispute service, where there is one, and we tell you the deadline on a bond claim or rent increase and what has to be lodged before it. We don't prepare or lodge tribunal applications, and we can't take on evictions or a matter a tribunal is already handling.
No win, no fee. We'll tell you straight if we don't think we can win it.
What doesn't work
- Disputing every item the same way. The official examples put stains, burns and tears on the damage side. Your case is clearest on the items they list as wear.
- Negotiating past the deadline. In Queensland, if you don't send Form 16 within 14 days, the bond is paid as the first request directed.
- Agreeing in the bond system to keep the peace. In Victoria the RTBA repays the bond once everyone on it agrees how it should be paid.
- Relying on memory instead of the entry report. The report and dated photos are what show a mark was there before you moved in.
- Accepting the price of brand new carpet or paint without asking its age. In WA the Commissioner weighs depreciation and expects the landlord to show how old the item was.
Common questions
Can the agent charge me to repaint the walls?
The NSW Government lists faded, chipped or cracked paint as fair wear and tear, and an unapproved, poor quality paint job as damage. In WA a landlord is asked to show when the walls were last painted, and the Commissioner weighs depreciation. Ask the agent in writing for the quote and the date of the last paint job.
The agent wants the full cost of new carpet. Do I have to pay it?
Carpet worn or flattened by everyday use is fair wear and tear in the NSW and RTA examples. Where there is real damage, Consumer Protection WA says a landlord may not be able to claim the full cost of a replacement if it leaves them better off. Ask for the carpet's age and the quote in writing.
The dispute service says it can't make the agent back down. What now?
In Queensland that's how conciliation works: it is voluntary and the conciliators don't decide who is right. If it doesn't settle, the RTA issues a Notice of unresolved dispute, which refers it to QCAT. In Victoria, if you can't agree, RDRV can arrange a hearing where a member decides.
Can someone deal with the agent for me?
Yes. Ajust's team writes to the agent with the facts from your lease and condition reports and takes it to the agency's principal if they refuse. In NSW the tenant advice services also give assistance and advocacy. Neither stops your state's bond deadline, so lodge your dispute step on time.
- NSW Government: Fair wear and tear versus damage in rental properties
- NSW Government: Rental property condition reports
- NSW Government: Resolving residential tenancy disputes
- Residential Tenancies Authority (Qld): Fair wear and tear
- Residential Tenancies Authority (Qld): Bond refunds
- Residential Tenancies Authority (Qld): RTA dispute resolution service
- Consumer Affairs Victoria: Bond claims and refunds
- Rental Dispute Resolution Victoria: Help for renters
- Consumer Protection WA: Evidence for bond claims
- Consumer Protection WA: Security bond release applications
- NCAT: Fees at NCAT
- NCAT: Representation

Still owed? We'll take it from here.
Other
General
Issues
Read about the issues consumers are facing. Have a different issue? You can still make a complaint.
